By June 1872, Antonio Sivori was the proprietor of St. Mark’s Restaurant at 27th Street and Broadway, situated inside the newly-completed Stevens House. Designed by the country’s leading architect, Richard Morris Hunt, the mansard-capped building was the first apartment complex of its kind. The eight-story structure occupied the entire south side of 27th Street between Broadway and Fifth Avenue, and yet it contained only eighteen luxury suites.1 Then thirty-nine years old, Sivori appears to have operated this restaurant for only about one year. Well-educated and fluent in six languages, he should have been able to work well with members of high society, but for some reason, he kept moving from job to job throughout his career, sometimes working at places you might least suspect.2
St. Mark’s Restaurant (1872)
Although St. Mark’s was not an Italian restaurant, it offered ice cream flavors like pistache, tutti frutti, and “fancy” Neapolitan, as shown on the à la carte menu below. In the early 1870s, there were only about 12,000 Italians living in New York, mostly from the northern regions.3
On the morning of June 26, 1872, the Alumni Association of the General Theological Seminary met for breakfast at St. Mark’s. This set menu reflects the French, English, German, and American influences that comprised the main themes of New York cuisine.
Whiskey-manufacturer George W. Kidd hosted a dinner at St. Mark’s for fellow members of the New York Yacht Club in November 1872.
The cover is inscribed “Commodore Bennett,” referring to James Gordon Bennett, Jr., the flamboyant publisher of the New York Herald, and with the name of his large schooner “Dauntless,” the Club’s flagship. These notations transform this sugary Victorian illustration into a comic scene, showing the thirty-one-year-old sportsman being admired by two young women.
In December 1866, Bennett won the first trans-oceanic yacht race, sailing from New York to the Isle of Wight through raging winter seas. The stirring contest boosted the circulation of the Herald, and made Bennett an accredited leader of the smart set. He soon became the youngest Commodore in the Club’s history. The notations may have been made by a friend and fellow yachtsman who left this menu behind after the dinner. Although it is probably a coincidence, Sivori was said to have been a life-long reader of the Herald. In addition to his linguistic talents, Sivori was also able to write well, reportedly composing articles for the city’s newspapers.4
|The New York Yacht Regatta by Currier & Ives (1869)|
The dinner at St. Mark’s was a modest affair for these wealthy yachtsmen. With Commodore Bennett in the lead, one hundred members of the New York Yacht Club hosted a banquet at Delmonico’s in December 1871 for Grand Duke Alexis of Russia. This lavish affair reportedly cost $5,000, or about $95,000 in today’s dollars. At the time, little could they have imagined that the period of economic prosperity that followed the Civil War would soon be coming to an abrupt end.
In the spring of 1873, following the closure of his restaurant, Sivori began working for Delmonico’s, and then branched out, doing catering jobs for the Windsor Hotel, the caterer George E. Greene & Son, and the Union Square Hotel. During this dark and uncertain period, Sivori seems to have taken work where he could find it, networking with friends, colleagues, and former employers to himself afloat.
Windsor Hotel (1873)
The menu below from the Windsor Hotel is dated only four days after the Great Panic of 1873. The luxury hotel had recently opened (or was just then opening) on Fifth Avenue at 47th Street, far from the turmoil that was engulfing the city’s financial center. Featuring cold dishes like fillet of beef à la Lucullus, buffalo tongue à la gelée, and boned reed birds à la Perigord, this elegant buffet supper may have been related to the début of the hotel.
Surprisingly, nine of the forty-five menus supposedly saved by Sivori bear the name “Delmonico.” They come from dinners, banquets, and late suppers in the mid-1870s, many years after Sivori’s apprenticeship at this restaurant, raising the question as to whether these particular menus originated from some other source. However, in 1893, the New York Times reported that “for seven years, under Charles Delmonico, (Sivori) was caterer for most of the great balls in New York.”5 According to the historical evidence provided by these menus, Sivori was one of the city’s foremost caterers for about that period of time. However, they also show that he was associated with Delmonico’s for only about two of those seven years. The menu below comes from a late supper on May 2, 1873.
Chef Charles Ranhofer often named dishes that he created after French writers and their literary works. One of the entrees shown below is named after Madame de Sévigné, the preeminent writer of epistles in the seventeenth century. The sorbet is named after Victor Hugo’s Marion de l’Orme, a drama about a courtesan in the 1640s.
According to custom, only a few simple desserts were served at dinners where there were no women present, as shown on the above menu, and also on the one below dated June 16, 1873, three months before the financial collapse. Ornamental typeface was then coming into vogue, bringing a stylistic flair to such menus. The printer employed a popular font design called Monastic for the quirky headings on these menus.
During the bitter winter of 1873-74, the entire country sank into a great depression, bringing misery to the working poor and masses of unemployed. Lorenzo Delmonico, founder of the eponymous restaurant that his nephew Charles was now running, came out of retirement to supervise several soup kitchens like the one illustrated below on Centre Street. During a six-week period, Lorenzo Delmonico estimated that he fed 71,892 destitute people in one ward alone. “I visited frequently the kitchens and the house for the supply of the soup,” he reported, “and I saw few, if any, of those who were…asking for relief who did not seem needy and deserving.”6
Delmonico’s restaurant even felt the pinch of the hard economic times to some extent. While talking to a newspaper reporter, Charles Delmonico recalled that there used to be several bottles of wine on every table at their uptown branch on 14th Street, “but now, if we hear a cork pop, we turn to see where it is, and it is generally a bottle of Bass.” Nevertheless, the upper classes still had money to spend, as shown by this dinner held for the second annual reunion of the Yale Alumni Association on December 12, 1873.
The Medical Faculty of New York University held its annual dinner on December 19, 1873.
These refined banquets took place at a time when everyday life was becoming increasingly desperate for many people. In January 1875, Frank Leslie’s Illustrated Newspaper published this chaotic scene titled: “The Red Flag in New York,” showing mounted police driving riotous “communist workingmen” from Tompkins Square, only twelve blocks from Delmonico’s.
Three scarce menus below come from unidentified banquets at Delmonico’s in 1874, the first full year of the great depression, when the number of such catered events in New York may have significantly decreased.
In April 1875, a banquet was held for Carl Schurz, honoring one of the most widely admired statesmen in the country. After achieving success as a general in the Civil War, Schurz went on to become the first German-born citizen to be elected to the Senate. German-Americans comprised thirty-five percent of the city’s population, making it the second-largest ethnic group. Sivori was probably not working for Delmonico’s by this late date, suggesting that he may have saved this menu as a personal memento.
George E. Greene & Son (1874)
Dated January 28, 1874, the silk menu below is simply marked with the name of the caterer and his address at 15 East 30th Street.7
In the next post, we will pick up the story at Union Square Hotel, where Sivori’s title changed from “caterer” to “steward” in February 1874, indicating that he had finally become a full-time employee of this hotel.
1. Opening in 1870, the “Stuyvesant” at 142 East 18th Street is generally regarded as the first apartment building in New York. It was also designed by Richard Morris Hunt. The luxurious Stevens House proved to be ahead of its time and was eventually transformed into the transient Victoria Hotel in 1879.
2. In the widely-reported dispute in 1878, Mrs. Paran Stevens, the unpleasant owner of the Stevens House, unsuccessfully tried to evict an Italian barber named Thomaselli who was subletting the basement of Ward & Hubbell’s store in the Stevens House. There is no evidence that Sivori had any run-ins with this notoriously difficult socialite, but it is not out of the question. In 1871, Sivori got into a legal wrangle that was reported in the Tribune, and in 1880, the Times reported an incident where he displayed evidence of having a mercurial temperament.
3. There were a few Italian eateries in New York, such as the Caffè Moretti which began serving simple fare in a basement on Cedar Street near the financial district in the 1850s. Its proprietor, Stefano Moretti, also claimed to have been a seminarian in Italy before immigrating to the United States. William Grimes, Appetite City, 2009, p. 96.
4. New York Herald, 25 March 1893.
5. New York Times, 26 March 1893.
6. Thomas Lately, Delmonico’s, 1967, p. 153.
7. In 1872, Trow’s Directory of New York City incorrectly lists the address of this firm as 15 East 80th Street. Interestingly, this directory shows that a waiter named George Greene lived at 38 Cornelia Street in the West Village, just a few doors down from where Pō now operates, the little Italian restaurant established in 1993.